How to Choose the Perfect Fireplace Mantel

Your Guide to buying the best Fireplace Mantels


This buying guide will provide you with all the information you need to choose the perfect fireplace mantel for your home. We will discuss the different types of mantels available, the materials they are made of, and how to determine the size and style that will best fit your home. We will also provide helpful tips and advice to make sure you get the perfect mantel for your décor. Through our research and expertise, we will make sure you understand the necessary features and benefits for each mantel type. By the end of this guide, you will be equipped with the knowledge and confidence needed to purchase the perfect fireplace mantel for your home.

Key features

  1. Style - The style of the mantel, such as traditional, modern, or rustic, will affect the overall look of your fireplace.
  2. Material - Fireplace mantels can be made of wood, stone, marble, or metal, each with its own characteristics and benefits.
  3. Size - Make sure you choose a mantel that fits the size of your fireplace. You don’t want a mantel that looks too small or too large.
  4. Color - The mantel should complement the color of the fireplace and other décor in the room.
  5. Installation - Consider how you will install the mantel; some require more work than others.
  6. Price - Set a budget for yourself, and make sure to consider the cost of installation.

See the most popular Fireplace Mantels on Amazon

Important considerations


  • Style: Fireplace mantels can come in a variety of styles to match any decor. From classic to modern, there's a mantel to fit your design tastes.
  • Material: Fireplace mantels are available in a variety of materials, from wood to metal, to stone. This allows you to pick the perfect material for your style and budget.
  • Size: Fireplace mantels come in a range of sizes, so you can find one that fits perfectly with your existing fireplace and room decor.
  • Accentuates Fireplace: A fireplace mantel is a great way to add a touch of elegance to your fireplace, making it the focal point of the room.
  • Extra Storage: Fireplace mantels can provide extra storage for books, decorations, and other items, making them a functional addition to your home.
  • Easy Installation: Fireplace mantels are relatively easy to install, meaning you don't need a professional to install it for you.


  • Cost - Fireplace mantels can be expensive. They range in price depending on the style, material, and size of the mantel.
  • Installation - Fireplace mantels may require professional installation, which can add to their total cost.
  • Maintenance - Fireplace mantels require regular maintenance and cleaning to stay in good condition.
  • Design - It may be difficult to find the right design to match the existing architecture of your home or the style you are looking for.
  • Weight - Fireplace mantels are heavy and need to be attached securely to the wall; if not attached properly, the mantel can become loose and possibly fall.

Best alternatives

    Marble Surrounds - Marble surrounds are a unique, high-quality material used to frame the fireplace. They bring a touch of elegance and luxury to any home. Wooden Mantels - Wooden mantels come in various styles and finishes and are a great way to create a warm and inviting atmosphere. Stone Hearth - Stone hearths are made of natural stone and provide a durable, stable base for the fireplace. Metal Fireplaces - Metal fireplaces are a great option for those looking for a modern and contemporary design. They are strong and durable and can last for decades. Electric Fireplace Inserts - Electric fireplace inserts are perfect for those looking for a hassle-free, easy-to-install option. They provide a cost-effective way to enjoy the ambiance of a fireplace without the need for a chimney. Gas Fireplace Inserts - Gas fireplace inserts are a great option for those looking for convenience and efficiency. They are easy to install and provide warmth and ambiance.

Related tools, supplies, and accessories

  • Rope Lights - A decorative lighting option used to accent a mantel.
  • Cordless Drill - Used to mount a mantel onto the wall.
  • Screws - Necessary for securely mounting a mantel to the wall.
  • Level - Used to ensure the mantel is mounted perfectly level.
  • Decorative Objects - A variety of objects like vases, plants, and sculptures to add additional aesthetic appeal to the mantel.
  • Heat Resistant Paint - Used to paint the mantel in order to change its color.
  • Mantel Cover - A special material that comes in a variety of colors to protect a mantel from dust, dirt, and other debris.
  • Caulk - Used to fill in any gaps between the mantel and the wall.

Common questions

  1. What are the different types of Fireplace Mantels? Fireplace mantels come in a variety of materials and styles, including wooden, stone, brick, or metal mantels. They can be traditional, modern, rustic, or industrial in design.
  2. How do I measure for a Fireplace Mantel? Measure the width of the fireplace opening, as well as the height of the opening from the finished floor surface to the top of the opening. Make sure to account for any obstructions, such as the firebox, when measuring.
  3. What type of mantel is best for my fireplace? The best type of mantel will depend on the size and style of your fireplace. A metal mantel may be ideal for a modern-style fireplace, while a wood mantel may be a better fit for a traditional-style fireplace.
  4. What other factors should I consider when buying a mantel? Consider the size and style of your room and the décor you want to achieve. Also, make sure to consider the installation requirements and the tools, hardware, and materials you will need.
  5. Is there any maintenance required for a mantel? Maintenance requirements will depend on the material of the mantel. Generally, wood mantels should be dusted or wiped with a damp cloth from time to time. Metal mantels may need to be wiped with a damp cloth and polished regularly to maintain the finish.


An interesting fact about fireplace mantels is that they have been used for centuries as a way to symbolize status and wealth. In the Medieval era, fireplace mantels were especially ornate and lavish, featuring intricate carvings and sculptures. Even today, mantels are often seen as a symbol of luxury and prestige, although they can also be used to add a touch of charm and style to any home. According to the National Fire Protection Association, fireplace mantels are one of the oldest forms of interior decoration still in existence today. Source

Disclaimer: This buying guide was not created by humans, and it is possible that some of it's content is inaccurate or incomplete. We do not guarantee or take any liability for the accuracy of this buying guide. Additionally, the images on this page were generated by AI and may not accurately represent the product that is being discussed. We have tried to convey useful information, but it is our subjective opinion and should not be taken as complete or factual.