How to Choose the Right Mascara for You

Your Guide to buying the best Mascara

Overview

Mascara is a makeup staple for many women, and selecting the right one can make all the difference in your overall look. Whether you’re looking for a mascara that will add length and volume to your eyelashes or create a dramatic, smoky eye, this buying guide will help you find the perfect product for your needs. We’ll discuss the various types of mascara available, the different formulas and features, and tips on how to choose the right mascara for you.

Key features

  1. Type - Consider the type of mascara you want, such as waterproof, volumizing, lengthening, or curling.
  2. Color - Choose a color that complements your eye color and skin tone.
  3. Application - Consider whether you prefer a mascara with a wand, brush, or airbrush applicator.
  4. Ingredients - Buy a mascara that is formulated with natural ingredients to reduce the risk of skin irritation.
  5. Consistency - Look for a non-clumping mascara with a creamy texture that is easy to apply.
  6. Longevity - Choose a mascara that offers long-lasting wear and will not smudge or flake.
  7. Price - Determine a budget and find a mascara that offers the best value for the price.

See the most popular Mascara on Amazon

Important considerations

Pros

  • Lengthens and Volumizes Lashes: Mascara adds length and volume to lashes, making them look fuller and thicker.
  • Smudge-Proof Formula: Mascara typically contains wax and other ingredients that help create a smudge-proof look.
  • Durable Wear: Mascara is designed to last throughout the day without needing to be reapplied.
  • Easy to Apply: Mascara is easy to apply with just a few swipes of the wand.
  • Instant Impact: Mascara can instantly transform the look of your eyes, making them look bigger and brighter.
  • Versatile: Mascara can be used to create a variety of looks, from natural to dramatic.
  • Inexpensive: Mascara is typically very affordable, making it a great choice for those on a budget.
  • Wide Selection: There are a wide variety of mascaras available, so you can easily find one that fits your needs.

Cons

  • Smudging - Mascara can smudge and run down the face if you don't take the time to find the right formula for your skin type and specific needs.
  • Clumping - If you use too much mascara, you can end up with clumpy, spidery lashes.
  • Irritation - You may experience irritation and redness around the eyes if you choose a mascara with harsh ingredients or are allergic to certain ingredients.
  • Flaking - Some mascaras can flake and leave little black flakes on your face throughout the day.
  • Too Much - Applying too much mascara can cause your lashes to become weighed down and droop.
  • Removal - Removing mascara can be tricky and time consuming. You may need to use special makeup removers that can be harsh on the skin.

Best alternatives

  1. eyeliner - A liquid or pencil-based product used to define the eyes.
  2. pencil eyebrow liner - A soft pencil used to add definition and shape to brows.
  3. eyebrow powder - A product used to fill in and define eyebrows.
  4. lash primer - A product used before mascara to create a base and add volume.
  5. lash curler - A product used to curl eyelashes.
  6. false eyelashes - Artificial lashes used to add volume and length to eyelashes.
  7. eye shadow - A product used to add color to eyelids.

Related tools, supplies, and accessories

Common questions

  1. What type of Mascara should I buy? It depends on what look you are trying to achieve. Mascara comes in different formulas, such as volumizing, lengthening, curling, and waterproof. It also comes in different colors and finishes, such as matte or glossy. You'll want to experiment with different types until you find the one that works best for you.
  2. Is it better to buy drugstore mascara or high-end mascara? It really depends on your preferences and budget. Drugstore mascaras are typically cheaper and offer great quality. However, high-end mascaras typically have more luxurious packaging, premium formulas, and more innovative features.
  3. How often should I replace my mascara? You should replace your mascara every 3-4 months to avoid bacteria buildup. Also, if you notice the formula has changed or the wand is clumpy, then it’s time to replace it.
  4. What are some tips for applying mascara? Start with a clean lash comb or brush to separate your lashes. Gently wiggle the wand at the base of your lashes and sweep it up. Don't pump the wand in and out of the tube, as this will cause the formula to dry out. For a more dramatic look, add additional coats. Lastly, use a lash curler to help the mascara stick to your lashes.

Trivia

In 2014, a woman in Canada decided to dye her lashes with green and gold stripes in support of her country during the Sochi Winter Olympics. She made the mascara herself by combining green and gold eyeshadow with clear mascara. The idea quickly caught on and it wasn’t long before cosmetic companies began to offer their own versions of the Canadian-inspired Olympic mascaras. Source

Disclaimer: This buying guide was not created by humans, and it is possible that some of it's content is inaccurate or incomplete. We do not guarantee or take any liability for the accuracy of this buying guide. Additionally, the images on this page were generated by AI and may not accurately represent the product that is being discussed. We have tried to convey useful information, but it is our subjective opinion and should not be taken as complete or factual.