The Ultimate Guide to Buying Eggnog

Your Guide to buying the best Eggnog


Eggnog is an iconic seasonal treat that has been enjoyed for centuries. Whether you're looking for a classic recipe to try at home or a pre-made bottle from the store, this buying guide will help you find the perfect eggnog for any occasion. From understanding the different types of eggnog to learning about the ingredients and nutrition facts, we will provide you with all the information you need to make an informed purchase.

Key features

  1. Type: What type of eggnog do you want to buy? Consider whether you want classic eggnog, light eggnog, vegan eggnog, or alcohol-spiked eggnog.
  2. Flavors: Different brands of eggnog come in different flavors, such as original, chocolate, pumpkin spice, and more.
  3. Nutrition: Pay attention to the nutrition facts label. Consider the calories, sugar, fat, and other nutritional information provided.
  4. Size/Quantity: Different eggnog products come in different sizes and quantities. Consider whether you want a single-serve container, or a larger jug.
  5. Price: Price is usually a key factor when shopping for any product. Compare prices online or in store to get the best deal.

See the most popular Eggnog on Amazon

Important considerations


  • Nutrition: Eggnog is a great source of protein and vitamins, making it a nutritious holiday treat.
  • Flavour: Eggnog is traditionally flavoured with nutmeg and cinnamon, making it a delicious treat for the holiday season.
  • Versatility: Eggnog can be served chilled, heated, or blended with other ingredients to create a unique treat.
  • Customization: Eggnog recipes can be customized to fit individual tastes, allowing for a variety of variations.
  • Health Benefits: Eggnog is rich in vitamins and minerals, making it a healthier alternative to many traditional holiday treats.
  • Easy to Make: Eggnog is easy to make and can be whipped up in no time for a quick holiday treat.


  • Calorie Count: Eggnog is high in calories due to its cream and sugar content.
  • High in Sugar: Eggnog can contain high levels of added sugar, which can be an issue for those looking for a low sugar beverage.
  • Availability: Eggnog is usually available during the holiday season, so it may not be readily available at other times of year.
  • Shelf Life: Unopened cartons of eggnog typically have a short shelf life and need to be used within a few days of being opened.

Best alternatives

  1. Oat Milk - A dairy-free milk alternative made from oats.
  2. Coconut Milk - Rich and creamy dairy-free milk alternative made from coconut.
  3. Rice Milk - A dairy-free milk alternative made from cooked rice blended with water.
  4. Almond Milk - A dairy-free milk alternative made from ground almonds.
  5. Hazelnut Milk - A dairy-free milk alternative made from ground hazelnuts.

Related tools, supplies, and accessories

  • Cups - Disposable or reusable cups for serving eggnog.
  • Spoons - Spoons for stirring eggnog.
  • Egg Separator - A device or tool for separating yolks from whites.
  • Whisk - A kitchen tool for mixing liquids.
  • Nutmeg - A spice often used to flavor eggnog.
  • Cinnamon - A spice often used to flavor eggnog.
  • Garnishes - Optional toppings such as whipped cream, ground nutmeg or cinnamon, or cinnamon sticks.

Common questions

  1. What type of Eggnog is best for me?
    • It depends on your personal preference and what you plan to do with the Eggnog. If you plan to drink it, you should look for an eggnog that is made with high-quality milk and cream, as well as natural flavors. For baking, you should look for a pre-sweetened variety.
  2. What is the shelf-life of Eggnog?
    • Unopened store-bought Eggnog typically has a shelf-life of three to five weeks. Once opened, it should be consumed within four to five days.
  3. Is Eggnog safe to consume when pregnant?
    • It is generally recommended that pregnant women avoid consuming raw or unpasteurized dairy products, including Eggnog, due to the risk of bacterial infection.
  4. What is the difference between regular Eggnog and vegan Eggnog?
    • Regular Eggnog is made with milk, cream, eggs, sugar, and spices, while vegan Eggnog is made with plant-based milks, such as almond or soy, and typically contains no eggs or dairy products.


One interesting fact about eggnog is that it has been around since medieval times! In the Middle Ages, the drink was made with a combination of wine or ale, milk, eggs, and spices. In the 1700s, rum became the preferred alcohol used in eggnog, and that tradition continues today. In the United States, eggnog is traditionally served around the holidays. SOURCE

Disclaimer: This buying guide was not created by humans, and it is possible that some of it's content is inaccurate or incomplete. We do not guarantee or take any liability for the accuracy of this buying guide. Additionally, the images on this page were generated by AI and may not accurately represent the product that is being discussed. We have tried to convey useful information, but it is our subjective opinion and should not be taken as complete or factual.